Tuesday, October 23, 2012

‘Close drain flowing into forest’ Hindustan Times 22 October 2012




Acting tough following yet another Public Interest Litigation (PIL), the Allahabad High Court, in an interim order, has directed the civic agencies to cement the drain which allegedly overflows into the green area of Sai Upvan city forest in Ghaziabad. The court has also directed that there should be sewage treatment plant (STP) to protect the water of river Hindon from pollution. The interim order came from Acting Chief Justice Amitava Lala and Justice Ashok Srivastava on a PIL filed by Ghaziabad councillor Rajendra Tyagi. He had filed the PIL against the proposed golf course by the Ghaziabad Development Authority (GDA) over 81 acres of the Sai Upvan city forest.
Tyagi had also alleged that a drain was flowing into the forest area and the sewage was destroying the trees.
In his PIL, Tyagi had also requested that the court stop any non-forest activity in the area and direct the agencies to initiate a reforestation drive. He also wanted the court to ensure that no untreated sewage is dumped into River Hindon and that the drain was cemented.
Also stating that there should be substantial development in this regard — which should also be reported to the court — the court order also stated: “In case of failure, the Municipal Commissioner of Ghaziabad Nagar Nigam will be directed to be personally present before this court.”
The court also connected Tyagi’s PIL to another PIL filed by Alok Kumar, vice-president of Ghaziabad RWA Federation (Indirapuram zone). Kumar had also moved court against the proposed golf course project and had filed a supplementary affidavit along with his main petition which called for better implementation of the UP Apartment Act 2010.
Earlier, in an interim order on October 4 over Kumar’s PIL, the court had ordered that status quo be maintained for Sai Upvan and Kanha Upvan green areas. In its counter affidavit, the GDA had stated that no project had be en finalised as yet and requested that the interim order be vacated.

Water body authority in limbo (Hindustan Times 22 October 2012)



More than two years after the Delhi government announced formation of a water body authority, officials are still "working out modalities". The government claims to have expedited work to form the authority which will protect and manage the 600-odd water bodies left in the Capital.
"We're identifying all water bodies currently falling under the jurisdiction of various land-owning agencies such as Delhi Development Authority, Delhi Jal Board or the three municipal corporations. We're seeking - from these agencies -their existing action plans so that we can prepare a holistic plan and form the authority," a senior government official told Hindustan Times on Monday.
"We want to avoid duplication. For example, Delhi Jal Board also prevents pollution of water bodies. We're working out modalities for one unified authority," he said.
The government claims that the delay in formation of the authority does not mean the water bodies are not being protected. "For example, we're writing to the East Delhi municipal corporation for protection of a water body at Mandawali in Shahadra. Debris had been dumped there after construction works. We're telling the corporation to carry out plantation work in the area," he said.  
The government also claimed that it is committed to protect marshes - a mix of wetland and grassland - near Jahangirpuri in North Delhi. "DMRC is building a Metro line in the area and has set up a temporary depot for storage of material. The area is under Delhi Jal Board and DDA. We will go for plantation in the area after the Metro construction is over. We believe parks and water bodies can co-exist," the official said.  
"After the national green tribunal (NGT) told officials to clear debris from the Yamuna riverbed, we have initiated measures that the order is followed in toto," he said. The tribunal observed early this month that the debris was causing pollution and was hazardous to the river ecosystem, flow of water and to the inhabitants who use the water.
These actions are being taken after Yamuna Jiye Abhiyan, a civil society group, asked the government to protect waterbodies and marshes from pollution and encroachment.

Monday, October 1, 2012

Green the dirty drains (The Hindu 29 September 2012)



Manoj Misra
·         The Hindu Kushak Nullah in Sewa Nagar near Nehru Stadium in New Delhi . Photo: V.V. Krishnan.
Rather than turning their faces away from ganda nalas that happen to be essential to Delhi’s drainage system, authorities and residents should try protecting and greening them
There is hardly any town in the country that does not have its ganda (dirty) nala (drain). In many places the ganda nala has become a part of the city’s psyche and even the city’s directional landmark. Delhi today boasts of 22 such major drains and both Meerut and Saharanpur have at least one each.
Look closely and you will find that each one of them is the combined output of a network of many such smaller nalas, some of which might even be originating from your own house, housing complex or the locality. Ever given a thought to these nalas, their origin and if they were always ganda?
The fact is that most, if not all, are the creation of the natural topography of the place in question and originated as storm water drains that carried the high flows during monsoon rains to either yet another drain or to a nearby water body or a river. In case of Delhi, it is the river Yamuna that has acted as the end destination of the city’s high flows. Thus these nalas were essential features of the natural drainage system of a town or city. Also in olden times, most of them acted as the town’s greenways and sites of recreation. It was much later and mostly during the last and the present century that we as part of our ‘development’ process converted them into ganda nalas.
Anything that is ganda abhors us and we have a tendency to wish or shoo it out of sight. It is also a fact that many of these ganda nalas exhale nauseating stench and become a source of vector borne diseases, especially when water in them tends to stagnate. No wonder there is a frequent clamour from affected people to seek their covering and concretisation.
But is it the ganda nala which is at fault deserving to be ‘fixed’ by the municipal authorities? Travel to a ‘developed’ western nation, and one is hard put to locate such ganda nalas? Surely they exist there, too, but have mostly been ‘fixed’ either under a road, a culvert, a parking site or into pipes. But if that was the correct ‘solution’, then why is there now, a growing clamour to “daylight” such infrastructure?
“Day lighting” or a ‘greening of grey (concrete) infrastructure’ is the process by which cities like Philadelphia in the U.S. endeavour to ‘green’ themselves, by rediscovering their lost or hidden streams and storm water drains and then expose them back to the elements. This is taken up even when the costs for such reversal prove prohibitive as a lot of effort, including enabling science, technology and legislation is required to re-nature such sites.
Not many might recall that in the year 1996, a dissertation by researcher Pallavi Kalia at the TVB School of Habitat Studies, New Delhi looked at the drainage system in the city of Delhi and then tested successfully the following hypothesis: “ The natural drainage channels, existing as a part of a city’s fabric, if developed through capitalising on their inherent characteristics, can be transformed from being corridors of filth and squalor, into means of reinforcing the imageability of the city, apart from making it functionally more efficient and ecologically more sustainable.”
While the referred study had focussed primarily on the Barapula drainage sub-system in Delhi, its applicability to the rest of the city was found to be obvious.
Now as Delhi bids for a heritage city and a world class city status, it would be best advised to not limit its ‘green city’ claim to just the tree cover that it has justifiably achieved. How it protects and suitably develops its natural drainage channels and reclaim those that it has already lost shall be the litmus test of its claim to a world class city. And since the tentacles of its natural drainage system spreads to every nook and corner of the city, it shall as much be the responsibility of the State authorities as of every resident of this city to work towards protection, preservation and improvement of its natural drains.
The role of the city’s residents and their associations (RWAs) in transforming every filthy drain in the city into a welcome greenway is immense. For where does the ‘filth’ that clogs the drains actually emanate from? Secondly, does it not make much better sense to appreciate, value and work together to clean and green our drains now, rather then spend a fortune at a later date to “daylight” them, a la many cities in the West?
(The writer is the Convener of Yamuna Jiye Abhiyaan)